28 See's Candies chocolates ranked

In a company famed for its brittles, truffles and lollipops—all of which we love—it’s almost shocking that our favorite came down to an unsung hero: See’s own take on a peanut-butter cup. The center is smooth and pings all the right points in your brain: It’s salty, it’s buttery, it’s pleasantly but not cloyingly sweet and, above all else, it actually tastes like you’re eating a natural nut butter (unlike most of its competitors). Bundled in See’s classic and silky milk chocolate, it’s a gem that’s been hiding in plain sight.

“It’s the anti-Reese’s. You can actually taste peanut butter.” –MJ